4.7 / 10 (based on 38 reviews)
Mike is a big 30-year-old lug who doesn’t want to grow up. He works as an EMS technician but spends his free time watching hockey and hanging out with scruffy slacker Weasel in the small house they share in New Haven, Connecticut. Mike gets a big slap upside the head when his friend Jimmy, well-known for his brief relationships, decides to marry soulmate Marcia and invites Mike to be his best man. Realizing that his own life is going nowhere, Mike tries to rekindle his his relationship with perky ex-girlfriend Shawna, who is working toward her second degree at Yale.
Genre: Comedy
Main Cast: Mike O’Malley, Mark Rosenthal, Will Arnett, Kate Walsh
Creators: Les Firestein, Mike O’Malley
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 2 episodes, 30-minute runtime
Shows Most Like The Mike O’Malley Show (1999)
Welcome to the Family (2013)
5.6 / 10 (based on 1093 reviews)
Chronicles how cultures collide when a white family and a Latino family are bonded together by their children who fall in love followed quickly by an unplanned pregnancy.
Genre: Comedy
Main Cast: Mary McCormack, Justina Machado, Ella Rae Peck, Mike O’Malley
Creators: Mike Sikowitz
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 12 episodes, 22.0-minute runtime
Flaked (2016)
7.2 / 10 (based on 11827 reviews)
A recovering alcoholic faces reality after a life changing accident in Venice Beach, California.
Genre: Comedy, Drama, Romance
Main Cast: Will Arnett, David Sullivan, Ruth Kearney, George Basil
Creators: Will Arnett, Mark Chappell
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 14 episodes, 30.0-minute runtime
The Millers (2013)
6 / 10 (based on 5661 reviews)
A divorced reporter, looking forward to the single life, finds his parents’ marital problems derail his plans.
Genre: Comedy
Main Cast: J.B. Smoove, Margo Martindale, Will Arnett, Nelson Franklin
Creators: Gregory Thomas Garcia
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 34 episodes, 22.0-minute runtime
Kirstie (2013)
5 / 10 (based on 931 reviews)
After his adoptive mother dies, a 26-year-old man tries to connect with his biological mother, a Broadway star.
Genre: Comedy
Main Cast: Kirstie Alley, Eric Petersen, Michael Richards, Rhea Perlman
Creators: Marco Pennette
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 12 episodes, 30.0-minute runtime
In the late 90s, a TV show briefly flickered across the screens of American households, only to vanish almost as quickly as it appeared. This was The Mike O’Malley Show, a sitcom that hoped to capture the hearts of viewers but ended up as a footnote in television history. Let’s take a closer look at this show, why it didn’t catch on, and its place in the broader landscape of TV comedies.
The Premise
At its core, The Mike O’Malley Show was about a 30-year-old guy named Mike, played by the eponymous Mike O’Malley, navigating life with his friends and family. The show aimed to offer a slice-of-life look at the everyday challenges and quirks of being an adult. On paper, it was a concept that had worked for many sitcoms before and has continued to work for many since. So, what went wrong?
A Short Run
First off, the show had a remarkably brief run. NBC aired only two episodes in September 1999 before pulling the plug. In the world of TV, where shows often need time to find their footing, this was the equivalent of not even finishing your first lap in a marathon. Six episodes were produced, but the remaining four never saw the light of day on NBC. For a show to be canceled so quickly, it’s clear that something didn’t resonate with viewers or the network.
The Characters
Beyond Mike, the show featured a cast of characters that included his best friend, his sister, and his parents. These characters were designed to provide a mix of support and comedic conflict for Mike, creating opportunities for humor and heartfelt moments. However, one of the criticisms of the show was that the characters felt underdeveloped. In a landscape filled with memorable and quirky sitcom personalities, the characters of The Mike O’Malley Show struggled to stand out.
The Humor
Humor is subjective, and what makes one person laugh can leave another person cold. The humor in The Mike O’Malley Show leaned towards the conventional, with a mix of physical comedy and situational humor. While there’s nothing inherently wrong with this approach, the show didn’t manage to bring a unique voice to the table. At a time when sitcoms like Friends and Frasier were dominating the airwaves with their sharp wit and distinctive characters, The Mike O’Malley Show failed to carve out its niche.
Timing and Competition
The late 90s were a crowded time for television, especially for sitcoms. The Mike O’Malley Show was up against stiff competition, not just in terms of direct time slot rivals but also in the broader context of what was available to watch. With so many options, a new show needed to make a strong impression right out of the gate. Unfortunately, this show didn’t manage to do that, getting lost in the shuffle.
Lessons Learned
While it’s easy to look back and point out where The Mike O’Malley Show might have gone wrong, it’s also important to recognize the lessons it offers for television production. One key takeaway is the importance of character development. Viewers need to connect with characters, finding something relatable or aspirationally engaging about them. Another lesson is about finding a unique voice or angle. In a crowded market, differentiation is key.
The Aftermath
The quick cancellation of The Mike O’Malley Show could have been a career setback for those involved, but that wasn’t necessarily the case. Mike O’Malley, for instance, went on to have a successful career in television and film. He’s perhaps best known for his role as Burt Hummel on Glee, a role that showcased his range and earned him critical acclaim. This goes to show that even though projects may fail, talent can persevere and find success elsewhere.
A Cult Following?
Many shows that were initially considered failures have gone on to achieve a cult status, finding their audience years after being taken off the air. While The Mike O’Malley Show hasn’t quite reached that level, it’s a curious artifact for those interested in 90s television or the careers of those involved. The few episodes that exist are like a time capsule, offering a glimpse into a show that could have been but never quite was.
Conclusion
In the grand scheme of things, The Mike O’Malley Show is a blip on the radar of TV history. Its quick cancellation serves as a reminder of the harsh realities of television production, where not every show gets the chance to grow and evolve. However, examining shows like this can provide valuable insights into the ingredients needed for a successful sitcom: distinctive characters, a unique voice, and perhaps a bit of luck. While The Mike O’Malley Show may not have left a lasting impact on the television landscape, it’s a fascinating case study in what happens when a show doesn’t quite click with its intended audience.