6.9 / 10 (based on 522 reviews)
Ex-cop J.W. Jackson searches for answers after a mysterious and deadly boat explosion on Martha’s Vineyard.
Genre: Mystery
Main Cast: Jesse Metcalfe, Sarah Lind, Eric Keenleyside, Chelsea Hobbs
Creators: Philip R. Craig
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 4 episodes
Shows Most Like Martha’s Vineyard Mysteries (2020)
The Crossword Mysteries (2019)
7.4 / 10 (based on 498 reviews)
Tess, a Sentinel crossword editor, helps Detective Logan solve murder mysteries.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Romance
Main Cast: Lacey Chabert, Brennan Elliott, Barbara Niven, John Kapelos
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 6 episodes, 90.0-minute runtime
Mystery 101 (2019)
7.6 / 10 (based on 1322 reviews)
Amy, a college professor teaching “Whodunnit” fiction and amateur sleuth, helps the police and Detective Travis solve murder mysteries.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery
Main Cast: Jill Wagner, Kristoffer Polaha, Robin Thomas, Preston Vanderslice
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 7 episodes
Picture Perfect Mysteries (2019)
6.7 / 10 (based on 499 reviews)
Allie is a photographer with a studio. She’s also an amateur sleuth, who helps Detective Sam solve murder mysteries.
Genre: Crime, Mystery, Romance
Main Cast: Alexa PenaVega, Carlos PenaVega, Trezzo Mahoro, Sunita Prasad
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 3 episodes
Hailey Dean Mystery (2016)
7.3 / 10 (based on 483 reviews)
Ex DA’s prosecutor, now therapist Hailey Dean and her investigator friend, Finch, solve murder cases.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery
Main Cast: Kellie Martin, Viv Leacock, Matthew MacCaull, Lucia Walters
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 9 episodes, 90.0-minute runtime
Aurora Teagarden Mysteries (2015)
7.4 / 10 (based on 1805 reviews)
Aurora/Roe, a librarian and amateur sleuth, investigates and solves murders with help from her friends in Real Murders Club.
Genre: Crime, Mystery
Main Cast: Candace Cameron Bure, Marilu Henner, Ellie Harvie, Peter Benson
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 17 episodes, 90.0-minute runtime
Martha’s Vineyard Mysteries is a series that has caught the attention of many since its debut in 2020. Based on the books by Philip R. Craig, the series unfolds on the picturesque island of Martha’s Vineyard. It combines the charm of a small town with intriguing mysteries that keep viewers hooked. This article takes a closer look at what makes this series stand out, from its setting and characters to the mysteries themselves and the community’s response.
The Setting: More Than Just a Backdrop
Martha’s Vineyard, an island located south of Cape Cod in Massachusetts, is renowned for its stunning landscapes, historic charm, and, of course, as a summer haven for the rich and famous. However, in Martha’s Vineyard Mysteries, the island serves as more than just a picturesque backdrop. It’s a character in its own right, with its unique culture, history, and community playing a pivotal role in each episode.
The series does an excellent job of showcasing the island’s beauty, from its serene beaches to its quaint towns. But it also doesn’t shy away from the complexities of living in such a place. The isolation of island life, the tight-knit community, and the seasonal influx of tourists all add layers to the mysteries and the characters’ interactions.
Characters That Feel Like Neighbors
At the heart of Martha’s Vineyard Mysteries are its characters, particularly the protagonist, Jeff Jackson. A retired Boston detective with a knack for solving puzzles, Jeff embodies the spirit of Martha’s Vineyard. He’s laid-back yet determined, with a deep love for the island and its people. His background in law enforcement, combined with his personal connections on the island, makes him the perfect amateur sleuth.
Supporting characters, like Dr. Zee Madieras, the local medical examiner, and her father, the police chief, add depth to the series. Their relationships with Jeff and each other feel genuine, creating a sense of community that’s central to the show’s appeal. These characters aren’t just plot devices; they’re people you might know, making their adventures and interactions all the more engaging.
The Mysteries: A Blend of Tradition and Innovation
Each episode of Martha’s Vineyard Mysteries presents a new puzzle, ranging from mysterious deaths to hidden treasures and family secrets. What sets these mysteries apart is how they balance traditional elements of the genre with innovative twists.
For example, one episode might feature a classic whodunit set against the backdrop of a local festival, incorporating island traditions and lore into the investigation. Another episode could delve into the complexities of a decades-old case, using modern technology and forensic science to shed new light on the mystery.
This blend of old and new keeps the series fresh and exciting, ensuring that even the most seasoned mystery fans can’t always predict what’s coming next.
Community and Viewer Response
Since its debut, Martha’s Vineyard Mysteries has garnered a dedicated following. Fans appreciate the series for its engaging plots, relatable characters, and beautiful setting. Many have expressed how the show has made them feel connected to Martha’s Vineyard, even if they’ve never visited.
The series has also sparked interest in the island itself, with some fans planning trips to see the filming locations and experience the community firsthand. This has been a boon for local businesses and has helped to showcase Martha’s Vineyard’s charm to a wider audience.
Behind the Scenes
An interesting aspect of Martha’s Vineyard Mysteries is the effort put into maintaining the authenticity of the setting and stories. The production team works closely with locals to capture the essence of the island, from the dialect and customs to the specific details of the landscape. This attention to detail has not gone unnoticed by viewers, who often praise the show for its realism and respect for the source material.
Moreover, the adaptation from Philip R. Craig’s books to the screen has been handled with care. While some changes were made to fit the television format, the spirit of the novels is very much alive in the series. Fans of the books have generally been pleased with how their favorite characters and stories have been brought to life.
Conclusion
Martha’s Vineyard Mysteries offers a refreshing take on the mystery genre, combining the charm of a small island community with intriguing puzzles and relatable characters. Its success lies in its ability to transport viewers to Martha’s Vineyard, making them feel part of the community and invested in the mysteries unfolding on the screen.
Whether you’re a fan of the books, a lover of mystery series, or someone looking for a show that captures the essence of a unique place, Martha’s Vineyard Mysteries is worth checking out. With its blend of tradition and innovation, engaging characters, and beautiful setting, it’s a series that stands out in a crowded field.