7.6 / 10 (based on 5944 reviews)
DS Karen Pirie reopens the case of a murdered barmaid. Her investigation unearths flaws in the original 1996 inquiry.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery
Main Cast: Emer Kenny, Gemma McElhinney, Kevin Mains, Barrie Hunter
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 3 episodes, 120-minute runtime
Shows Most Like Karen Pirie (2022)
Sherwood (2021)
7.4 / 10 (based on 7123 reviews)
Two shocking and unexpected murders shatter an already fractured community leading to one of the largest manhunts in British history while threatening to inflame historic divisions sparked during the Miners’ Strike three decades before.
Genre: Crime
Main Cast: Adam Hugill, Sean Gilder, Tina Louise Owens, Grant Crookes
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
6 episodes
The Suspect (2022)
6.7 / 10 (based on 2508 reviews)
Doctor Joseph O’Loughlin a man who appears to have the perfect life and a successful career as a clinical psychologist. But nothing can be taken for granted. Even the most flawless existence is only a loose thread away from unravelling.
Genre: Drama, Mystery, Thriller
Main Cast: Imogen Daines, Tom McKay, Tara Lee, Bobby Schofield
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 5 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
Shetland (2013)
8.2 / 10 (based on 20260 reviews)
DI Jimmy Perez and his team investigate crimes within the close knit island community of Shetland.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery
Main Cast: Douglas Henshall, Alison O’Donnell, Steven Robertson, Mark Bonnar
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
7 seasons, 34 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
I Delitti Della Gazza Ladra (2022)
7.5 / 10 (based on 4170 reviews)
Editor Susan Ryeland gets drawn into a web of intrigue and murder when she receives Alan Conway’s unfinished manuscript of an Atticus Pünd mystery.
Genre: Drama, Mystery
Main Cast: Conleth Hill, Lesley Manville, Alexandros Logothetis, Tim McMullan
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 6 episodes, 45.0-minute runtime
Ridley (2022)
6.5 / 10 (based on 1713 reviews)
Retired Detective Alex Ridley is lured back into service as a consultant detective when his former protégée, Carol Farman, needs help cracking a complex murder case.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery
Main Cast: Adrian Dunbar, Bronagh Waugh, George Bukhari, Reece Douglas
Creators: Jonathan Fisher, Paul Matthew Thompson
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 4 episodes, 115.0-minute runtime
Annika (2021)
7.1 / 10 (based on 5062 reviews)
The sharp, witty and enigmatic DI Annika Strandhed, as she heads up a new specialist Marine Homicide Unit (MHU) that is tasked with investigating the unexplained, brutal, and seemingly unfathomable murders.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery
Main Cast: Nicola Walker, Jamie Sives, Katie Leung, Ukweli Roach
Creators: Nick Walker
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 6 episodes
Grace (2021)
7.3 / 10 (based on 4808 reviews)
Brighton-based Detective Superintendent Roy Grace, a hard-working police officer who has given his life to the job.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery
Main Cast: John Simm, Rakie Ayola, Richie Campbell, Laura Elphinstone
Creators: Russell Lewis
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 5 episodes, 90.0-minute runtime
Vigil (2021)
7.4 / 10 (based on 22267 reviews)
The mysterious disappearance of a Scottish fishing trawler and a death onboard a Trident nuclear submarine bring the police into conflict with the Navy and British security services.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery, Thriller
Main Cast: Suranne Jones, Rose Leslie, Shaun Evans, Paterson Joseph
Creators: Tom Edge
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 6 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
If you’re in the market for a new crime drama that doesn’t just follow the beaten path, you might want to check out “Karen Pirie,” which premiered in 2022. This ITV series brings a fresh perspective to the detective genre, focusing on a young, ambitious detective sergeant, Karen Pirie, as she reopens a historic murder case. The show is based on the “Cold Case” series of novels by Val McDermid, specifically “The Distant Echo,” and it’s a blend of mystery, character-driven storytelling, and a touch of Scottish charm.
The Premise
At the core of “Karen Pirie” is the unsolved murder of a barmaid, Rosie Duff, found stabbed to death in the historical city of St. Andrews, Scotland, in 1996. Fast forward 25 years, and the case is reopened due to a podcast that rekindles public interest. Karen Pirie, portrayed by Lauren Lyle, is tasked with leading the cold case unit, despite her relative inexperience and the skepticism of her colleagues. The narrative weaves between the past and present, exploring the initial investigation and the new efforts led by Pirie to uncover the truth.
Why It Stands Out
A Fresh Face in Crime Drama
First off, Karen Pirie herself is a departure from the typical detective archetype. She’s young, she’s not jaded, and she approaches her work with a mix of earnestness and sharp wit. Unlike many of her hard-boiled counterparts in the genre, she doesn’t carry the weight of the world on her shoulders, nor does she resort to questionable methods to get the job done. This makes her not just relatable but also a breath of fresh air in a genre that often leans heavily on its tropes.
The Scottish Setting
The show’s setting in St. Andrews adds another layer of intrigue. It’s not just the scenic beauty of Scotland that captures the viewer’s attention; it’s how the location plays into the narrative. The small-town setting, with its close-knit community and historical backdrop, adds depth to the story and the investigation. It’s a character in its own right, shaping the narrative and the people within it.
The Use of Time
The narrative’s dual timelines are cleverly used, not just for suspense but to deepen the viewer’s understanding of the characters and their motivations. By showing events from 1996 alongside the present-day investigation, “Karen Pirie” offers a nuanced exploration of how the past continually shapes our present. It’s a reminder that time doesn’t heal all wounds; sometimes, it just covers them up, waiting for someone like Karen Pirie to uncover the truth.
Supporting Cast and Character Development
While Lauren Lyle shines as Karen Pirie, the supporting cast also delivers compelling performances. Each character, from the original detectives involved in the case to the friends of the victim and the suspects, is well-drawn and complex. Their interactions with Pirie and each other add layers to the narrative, making the world of “Karen Pirie” rich and immersive.
What Sets It Apart from Other Crime Dramas
“Karen Pirie” doesn’t just rely on the shock value of crime or the thrill of the chase. It places equal importance on the why as much as the who. The series delves into the impact of crime on a community, the scars it leaves, and the lengths to which people will go to find closure or escape guilt. It’s a study in human nature as much as it is a crime drama.
Moreover, the series’ pacing sets it apart. It doesn’t rush through its plot or bombard the viewer with twists at every turn. Instead, it takes its time, allowing the story to unfold naturally, which makes the resolution all the more satisfying.
Challenges and Criticisms
No show is without its challenges or points of contention, and “Karen Pirie” is no exception. Some viewers might find the pacing slow, particularly those accustomed to more action-packed, fast-paced crime dramas. Additionally, the back-and-forth timeline can be confusing if you’re not paying close attention.
However, these aspects are also what many fans appreciate about the series. It’s a matter of preference, and for those who enjoy a more thoughtful, character-driven approach to crime storytelling, these are not so much criticisms as they are features.
Conclusion
“Karen Pirie” is a standout in the crowded field of crime dramas, offering a unique blend of character depth, narrative complexity, and a setting that enriches the story it tells. It’s a series that respects its audience’s intelligence, challenging them to piece together the puzzle alongside its protagonist. For those tired of the same old detective stories, Karen Pirie’s adventures in St. Andrews offer a compelling reason to stay in and watch just one more episode.