6.8 / 10 (based on 384 reviews)
Spin off from Holby City (1999) and Casualty (1986), taking place in and around Holby South police station and focusing on the police who work with the doctors and paramedics from Holby City and Casualty.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery
Main Cast: Cal MacAninch, Richard Harrington, Jimmy Akingbola, Zöe Lucker
Creators: Tony Jordan
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 20 episodes, 60-minute runtime
Shows Most Like Holby Blue (2007)
Van der Valk (2020)
6.8 / 10 (based on 3524 reviews)
A Dutch detective takes on criminal cases in Amsterdam using insightful human observation and his natural street smarts.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Thriller
Main Cast: Marc Warren, Maimie McCoy, Luke Allen-Gale, Elliot Barnes-Worrell
Creators: Chris Murray
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 6 episodes, 90.0-minute runtime
The Gulf (2019)
6.7 / 10 (based on 1424 reviews)
A detective’s personal and professional life start to unravel when she is involved in a fatal car accident and begins to lose her memory.
Genre: Crime
Main Cast: Kate Elliott, Ido Drent, Timmie Cameron, Dahnu Graham
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 14 episodes, 45.0-minute runtime
Bancroft (2017)
6.8 / 10 (based on 3745 reviews)
A dark thriller surrounding Elizabeth Bancroft, a senior detective with explosive secrets.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery, Thriller
Main Cast: Sarah Parish, Ryan McKen, Adam Long, Lee Boardman
Creators: Kate Brooke
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 7 episodes, 45.0-minute runtime
Keeping Faith (2017)
7.1 / 10 (based on 5442 reviews)
Faith, a small-town Welsh lawyer, is forced to cut short her extended maternity leave when her husband and business partner, Evan, goes missing. As the truth of his actions surface, Faith must fight to protect her family and her sanity.
Genre: Drama, Mystery, Thriller
Main Cast: Eve Myles, Bradley Freegard, Mark Lewis Jones, Hannah Daniel
Creators: Matthew Hall
Directors:
Writers:
3 seasons, 20 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
Smother (2021)
6.5 / 10 (based on 1637 reviews)
On the rugged coast of County Clare, Val Ahern’s husband is found dead at the foot of a cliff the morning after a family party. The matriarch starts to dig into the family’s secrets to find out who might be responsible.
Genre: Drama, Thriller
Main Cast: Dervla Kirwan, Gemma-Leah Devereux, Niamh Walsh, Seána Kerslake
Creators: Kate O’Riordan
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 6 episodes
Grace (2021)
7.3 / 10 (based on 4808 reviews)
Brighton-based Detective Superintendent Roy Grace, a hard-working police officer who has given his life to the job.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery
Main Cast: John Simm, Rakie Ayola, Richie Campbell, Laura Elphinstone
Creators: Russell Lewis
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 5 episodes, 90.0-minute runtime
The Pact (2021)
6.9 / 10 (based on 3817 reviews)
An unexplained death – and five friends bound together by a fragile pact of silence. What really happened that night in the woods?
Genre: Thriller
Main Cast: Laura Fraser, Julie Hesmondhalgh, Eiry Thomas, Heledd Gwynn
Creators: Pete McTighe
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 6 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
The Tunnel (2013)
7.8 / 10 (based on 9808 reviews)
A prominent French politician is found dead on the border between the U.K. and France, and two agents have to work together on behalf of their respective countries to find the murderer.
Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery, Thriller
Main Cast: Stephen Dillane, Clémence Poésy, Cédric Vieira, Angel Coulby
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
3 seasons, 24 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
Holby Blue, a British police procedural drama, hit the small screen in 2007, spinning off from the established medical dramas Holby City and Casualty. The show aimed to offer viewers a fresh perspective on the lives of those working within the criminal justice system, specifically focusing on the fictional Holby City Police. Despite its ambitions and connections to beloved series, Holby Blue had a relatively short lifespan, concluding after just two seasons. This piece explores the series’ intentions, its narrative and character dynamics, its reception, and ultimately, why it didn’t last longer.
The Genesis of Holby Blue
The creation of Holby Blue was a strategic move to capitalize on the popularity of its predecessors, Holby City and Casualty. The producers aimed to create a universe within Holby that fans could delve deeper into, exploring different facets of public service. The series was set in the same fictional city, intending to provide a crossover appeal for fans of the medical dramas. The show was produced by the BBC and was developed with high hopes of replicating the success of its sister shows.
The Core of Holby Blue
Plot and Setting
Holby Blue’s narrative centered around the day-to-day operations of the Holby City Police force, dealing with a wide range of crimes, from thefts and assaults to more complex and emotionally charged cases. The setting allowed for a gritty exploration of both the professional and personal lives of the officers and detectives, providing a platform for character development and drama.
Characters
The series boasted an ensemble cast, featuring characters such as DI John Keenan, a dedicated but flawed detective; DS Luke French, his ambitious and sometimes naive partner; and Inspector Jenny Black, the stern but fair leader of the team. The show did well to balance the focus across its cast, giving each character their own storylines and challenges to overcome.
Reception and Challenges
Upon its debut, Holby Blue received mixed reviews. Critics appreciated the attempt to merge the medical and crime genres but noted that the series sometimes struggled to find its unique voice amidst the crowded police procedural landscape. Viewership started strong, buoyed by curiosity and the established Holby City fanbase, but saw a decline as the series progressed.
One of the main challenges Holby Blue faced was its competition. In 2007, the airwaves were saturated with crime dramas, both from the UK and internationally. Shows like The Bill, a long-standing and beloved British series, and American imports such as CSI and Law & Order, dominated the genre. Holby Blue had to fight hard to stand out and attract a dedicated viewership.
Why It Didn’t Last
Despite its potential, Holby Blue was cancelled after just two seasons. Several factors contributed to its short run:
Struggle to Differentiate
One of Holby Blue’s biggest hurdles was establishing a distinct identity. While it aimed to leverage the popularity of Holby City and Casualty, it also needed to carve out its own niche. The series sometimes felt too familiar, not offering enough uniqueness to draw viewers away from their established favorites.
Viewer Fatigue
The late 2000s saw a saturation of police procedurals. With so many options available, viewers had their pick of the litter, making it difficult for newer shows like Holby Blue to maintain a steady audience. The series didn’t manage to introduce enough innovative elements to keep viewers hooked.
Timing and Scheduling
The timing of Holby Blue’s airing also played a role in its struggle to capture a larger audience. Competing against well-established shows in prime time slots, Holby Blue found it challenging to make a significant impact in the ratings.
Legacy and Conclusion
Despite its early exit, Holby Blue left a mark on the landscape of British television. It showcased the BBC’s willingness to experiment and expand on successful formulas. The series also provided a platform for several actors to showcase their talents, some of whom would go on to have successful careers in television and film.
In retrospect, Holby Blue was an ambitious project that, despite its best efforts, couldn’t quite find its footing. It serves as a case study in the challenges of launching a spin-off and the importance of differentiation in a crowded market.
For fans of the Holby universe, the series remains a fascinating “what could have been,” offering a glimpse into the lives of those on the other side of the emergency calls. While it may not have achieved the longevity of its sister shows, Holby Blue remains a noteworthy attempt to explore new narratives within an established world.