7.4 / 10 (based on 406 reviews)
A culinary guessing game in which bakers must decode what type of dessert was made, when all that’s left are a few clues. They have to recreate the recipe and the jury will determine how closely it matches the missing dessert.
Genre: Reality-TV
Main Cast: Natasha Babchak, Joel McHale, Curtis Stone, Yolanda Gampp
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 9 episodes
Shows Most Like Crime Scene Kitchen (2021)
Baking It (2021)
7.2 / 10 (based on 397 reviews)
Eight teams of two talented home bakers will compete and create outstanding savory and sweet creations for themed challenges in order to win a cash prize.
Genre: Game-Show, Reality-TV
Main Cast: Andy Samberg, Maya Rudolph
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 6 episodes
Lego Masters (2020)
7.5 / 10 (based on 2730 reviews)
LEGO enthusiasts participate in a series of competitions that begin with a single LEGO brick and concludes with inspiring, complex constructions.
Genre: Reality-TV
Main Cast: Will Arnett, Jamie Berard, Amy Corbett, Zack Macasaet
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
3 seasons, 23 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
The Hustler (2021)
7.8 / 10 (based on 716 reviews)
Join Craig Ferguson and a group of five suspects as they journey through a trivia show to find out who the Hustler truly is.
Genre: Game-Show
Main Cast: Craig Ferguson, Ryan Zamo, Jen Welter, Koren Rolle
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 18 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
Making It (2018)
7.9 / 10 (based on 1597 reviews)
Amy Poehler and Nick Offerman host a crafting series where incredibly talented people come together for a friendly competition.
Genre: Comedy, Reality-TV
Main Cast: Amy Poehler, Nick Offerman, Simon Doonan, Dayna Isom Johnson
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
3 seasons, 22 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
Great Chocolate Showdown (2020)
7.2 / 10 (based on 54 reviews)
Each week the talented batch of bakers will face with a range of creative and exciting chocolate-based competitions that will test their sweet imaginations and put their baking skills to the test. These challenges include everything from creating an out-of-this-world chocolate creation with a galactic mirror finish and baking an over-the-top spectacle cake, to re-imagining a classic campfire treat and creating a chocolate confection with a spicy kick. Some of the bakers may melt under the pressure and only one will taste sweet victory by claiming the title of Great Chocolate Showdown champion and the $50,000 grand prize.
Genre: Reality-TV
Main Cast: Anna Olson, Steven Hodge, Cynthia Stroud
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 16 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
Bake Squad (2021)
6.9 / 10 (based on 936 reviews)
Expert bakers elevate desserts with next-level ideas and epic execution. Now the battle is on to win over clients in need of very special sweets.
Genre: Game-Show, Reality-TV
Main Cast: Christina Tosi, Ashley Holt, Gonzo Jimenez, Maya-Camille Broussard
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 8 episodes, 35.0-minute runtime
Nailed It! Holiday! (2018)
7.7 / 10 (based on 1172 reviews)
Novice chefs compete in a holiday-themed cooking challenges to earn a $10,000 prize.
Genre: Reality-TV
Main Cast: Nicole Byer, Jacques Torres, Charity George, Jason Mantzoukas
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 13 episodes, 31.0-minute runtime
Cutthroat Kitchen (2013)
7.3 / 10 (based on 2108 reviews)
Chefs are asked to overcome major obstacles and acts of sabotage in this reality competition.
Genre: Game-Show, Reality-TV
Main Cast: Alton Brown, Jet Tila, Simon Majumdar, Antonia Lofaso
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
15 seasons, 193 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
Ellen’s Game of Games (2017)
5.4 / 10 (based on 1038 reviews)
Contestants compete for prizes in a series of games based on The Ellen Show, for a chance to win $100,000.
Genre: Game-Show
Main Cast: Ellen DeGeneres, Stephen Boss, Rachel Marsh, Steven Natale
Creators: Kevin A. Leman II, Ellen DeGeneres
Directors:
Writers:
4 seasons, 59 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
Holey Moley (2019)
7.1 / 10 (based on 1187 reviews)
Contestants put their miniature golf-and physical-skills to the test as they face off in out-of-this-world challenges on a supersized course.
Genre: Game-Show, Reality-TV
Main Cast: Joe Tessitore, Rob Riggle, Stephen Curry, Jeannie Mai Jenkins
Creators: Chris Culvenor
Directors:
Writers:
3 seasons, 36 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
Mental Samurai (2019)
5.7 / 10 (based on 189 reviews)
Contestants battle to answer questions accurately with speed and precision on a specially designed course.
Genre: Game-Show
Main Cast: Natalie Peyser, Rob Lowe, Russell Rope, Heather Hurley
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 19 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
“Crime Scene Kitchen” is a unique blend of culinary prowess and detective work, which premiered in 2021. Hosted by Joel McHale, the show features bakers who must deduce the dessert that was previously prepared in a kitchen based on the clues left behind. This concept takes the traditional baking competition to a whole new level, combining the thrill of a mystery with the creativity and skill of baking.
The Format
The show operates on a simple yet intriguing premise. Each episode consists of two rounds: the Dessert Round and the Showpiece Round. In the Dessert Round, teams are given a limited amount of time to scour the “crime scene” kitchen for clues. These clues range from flour on the counter, a used mixer, to remnants of ingredients in the trash. Based on their findings, teams must decide what dessert was made in the kitchen and then recreate it to the best of their abilities.
The Showpiece Round follows a similar format but challenges the teams to create a more complex dessert that fits a specific theme, again based on the clues provided. Judges, which include chef Curtis Stone and cake artist Yolanda Gampp, critique the desserts not only on their taste and presentation but also on how closely they match the supposed “crime scene” dessert.
Why It Stands Out
In a sea of cooking shows, “Crime Scene Kitchen” distinguishes itself through its unique blend of genres. It’s not just a baking show; it’s a mystery game and a strategic puzzle. Contestants need to be sharp in their observation and deduction skills, and flexible and creative in their baking. This combination keeps viewers on the edge of their seats, as they’re not only guessing who will bake the best dessert but also trying to solve the mystery themselves.
The Contestants
The show features a diverse cast of contestants, from professional pastry chefs to self-taught home bakers. This mix adds to the unpredictability and charm of the show. Some contestants rely on their refined technical skills, while others bring creativity and out-of-the-box thinking to the table. This diversity in backgrounds and approaches makes for an interesting dynamic and sometimes surprising outcomes.
Memorable Moments
One of the most memorable aspects of “Crime Scene Kitchen” is when contestants’ interpretations of the clues lead them down entirely different paths. For example, in one episode, teams were divided over whether a smudge of chocolate on a spatula indicated that a chocolate cake or chocolate cookies were made. Such moments not only add a layer of suspense but also highlight how subjective and tricky the art of deduction can be.
Another notable moment was when a team, convinced they were making a lemon meringue pie based on the clues, realized halfway through that they might be on the wrong track. Watching them pivot, with the clock ticking, added an intense layer of drama and showcased the contestants’ ability to adapt under pressure.
The Judges
The judges, Curtis Stone and Yolanda Gampp, bring a wealth of knowledge and expertise to the show. Stone, with his culinary background, focuses on the flavors and execution of the desserts, while Gampp, a renowned cake artist, critiques the presentation and creativity. Their differing perspectives ensure a well-rounded evaluation of the desserts. Their feedback is constructive, often providing the contestants with valuable insights into their baking and decision-making processes.
The Host
Joel McHale, primarily known for his comedic roles, brings a light-hearted and humorous tone to the show. His witty remarks and playful banter with the contestants and judges add a layer of entertainment, ensuring that the show doesn’t take itself too seriously. McHale’s hosting style is refreshing and keeps the mood upbeat, even in the most tense moments.
The Challenges
“Crime Scene Kitchen” is not without its challenges. Contestants must balance their time between investigating the kitchen for clues and actually baking their desserts. This time management aspect is critical, as spending too much time on one task can jeopardize their performance in the other. Additionally, the pressure of competing not only against other teams but also against the clock adds an exciting level of stress and urgency to the show.
Viewer Engagement
The show has a way of engaging viewers, inviting them to play along at home. As the contestants scour the kitchen for clues, viewers find themselves trying to piece together the puzzle as well. This interactive element is one of the show’s strengths, as it encourages audience participation and keeps them engaged throughout the episode.
Conclusion
“Crime Scene Kitchen” is a breath of fresh air in the realm of cooking competitions. Its unique premise, engaging format, and blend of skills required from the contestants make it stand out. Whether you’re a baking enthusiast, a mystery lover, or just looking for an entertaining show to watch, “Crime Scene Kitchen” offers something for everyone. It’s a show that proves the world of baking can be as unpredictable and thrilling as solving a mystery.