6.1 / 10 (based on 333 reviews)
Two opposing teams of comedians are given series of topics to debate.
Genre: Comedy, Game-Show
Main Cast: John Sergeant, Marcus Brigstocke, Rufus Hound, Sean Lock
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
4 seasons, 49 episodes, 30-minute runtime
Shows Most Like Argumental (2008)
Hypothetical (2019)
6.6 / 10 (based on 634 reviews)
Two teams of comedians are tested on their ability to deal with a series of ridiculous hypothetical scenarios.
Genre: Comedy, Game-Show
Main Cast: James Acaster, Josh Widdicombe, Sara Pascoe, Tom Allen
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
4 seasons, 32 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
Damned (2016)
7.3 / 10 (based on 1061 reviews)
Comedy set in the social services department of a local authority. Social workers Rose and Al swim against the tide of bureaucracy, deal with the absurdities of life and try to navigate their equally trying professional and personal lives.
Genre: Comedy
Main Cast: Jo Brand, Alan Davies, Kevin Eldon, Georgie Glen
Creators: Morwenna Banks, Jo Brand
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 12 episodes, 24.0-minute runtime
Jon Richardson: Ultimate Worrier (2018)
6.9 / 10 (based on 248 reviews)
Award-winning comedian and self-confessed obsessive worrier and organiser Jon Richardson attempts to analyse, assess and log every single one of his many, many worries.
Genre: Comedy
Main Cast: Jon Richardson, Lucy Beaumont, Rose Matafeo, Mae Martin
Creators: Charlie Bennett, Laura Gibson, Jonno Richards
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 18 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
When it comes to British panel shows, there’s a wide array to choose from, each with its unique flavor and charm. However, one that stands out for its blend of comedy and debate is “Argumental.” Launched in 2008, this show carved a niche for itself by offering something that was not just entertaining but also intellectually stimulating, at least in the realm of comedy.
The Premise
At its core, “Argumental” is a battle of wits and words. Two teams, each comprised of two individuals, go head-to-head on various topics. The catch? They don’t just argue for what they believe in. Instead, they might find themselves defending a position they personally disagree with. This twist adds a layer of challenge and humor, as contestants wrestle with arguments that might go against their grain, all in the spirit of good fun.
Format and Structure
The show is structured around several rounds, each with its own set of rules. Initially, the teams receive a topic and must argue for or against it. Subsequent rounds mix things up, introducing visual aids, guest contributors, and even physical demonstrations to bolster the arguments. The aim isn’t just to argue well but to entertain, persuading not only the opposing team but also the audience and the host.
Hosts and Panelists
Over its run, “Argumental” saw a change in hosts, starting with John Sergeant and later transitioning to Sean Lock and then to Marcus Brigstocke. Each brought their own style to the show, with Sergeant’s deadpan delivery contrasting with Lock’s and Brigstocke’s more overt comedic approaches.
The panelists, a rotating cast of comedians, writers, and television personalities, are the show’s lifeblood. Regulars like Rufus Hound and Marcus Brigstocke (before he became a host) provided continuity, while guest panelists kept the show fresh and unpredictable. Their quick wit and ability to think on their feet were crucial, turning even the most absurd argument into a moment of comedy gold.
Memorable Moments
“Argumental” is packed with memorable moments, many of which stem from the sheer absurdity of the arguments. For instance, watching a respected comedian passionately defend the indefensible or argue against something universally agreed upon was always a highlight. These moments not only showcased the panelists’ comedic talents but also their ability to engage in mental gymnastics, making the audience question their stance on various topics, if only for a second.
The Appeal
What makes “Argumental” appealing is its blend of comedy and debate. It’s not just about making people laugh; it’s about making them think. The show plays with the idea that arguments, even about the most serious topics, can be approached with humor and light-heartedness. This approach not only entertains but also subtly encourages viewers to consider multiple perspectives, even on seemingly cut-and-dry issues.
Educational Value
While “Argumental” is first and foremost a comedy show, it inadvertently serves an educational purpose. It demonstrates the art of argumentation, showcasing how to construct and deconstruct arguments effectively. For anyone interested in debate, rhetoric, or simply improving their persuasive skills, watching the panelists navigate their way through each challenge is both enlightening and inspiring.
Legacy
Though “Argumental” ended its run, its impact lingers. It proved that a show could be both funny and smart, challenging viewers to engage their brains while tickling their funny bones. It paved the way for other shows to blend comedy with other elements, whether it be education, sports, or even cooking.
Conclusion
“Argumental” remains a standout show in the crowded field of British panel shows. Its unique premise, engaging format, and talented cast of panelists ensured that it was not just another forgettable entry in the genre. Instead, it left a lasting impression, proving that comedy and intellect could coexist harmoniously. For fans of comedy, debate, or just good television, “Argumental” is a show that deserves a spot on the watchlist.