6.4 / 10 (based on 136 reviews)
TV series that takes a closer look into homicide investigations through interviews with potential suspects, re-enactments and in-depth examinations of the crime scene.
Genre: Documentary, Crime, Drama
Main Cast: Glenn Edward Gyorffy, Duncan McLellan, Stu Arthur, Nick Biskupek
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 29 episodes
Shows Most Like An Unexpected Killer (2019)
Buried in the Backyard (2018)
7.2 / 10 (based on 298 reviews)
It examines true crime stories of victims found buried in the most unsuspicious places.
Genre: Documentary, Crime
Main Cast: Sadie Medley, Rhoda Pell, Amir Mo, Kelly Ann Barrett
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
4 seasons, 52 episodes
The Murder Tapes (2019)
7.9 / 10 (based on 459 reviews)
Homicide investigations unfold through taped footage in Investigation Discovery’s true-crime series The Murder Tapes. The series provides an up-close perspective of murder cases, including footage from the initial crime scene investigations via body cam, home security tapes, and interrogation room tapes. The footage is interwoven with present-day interviews from friends, family and law enforcement directly involved in the investigations.
Genre: Crime
Main Cast: Dave DeAndrea, Rob LaColla Jr., Rachel Discenza-Smith, Jason Simpkins
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
5 seasons, 40 episodes, 45.0-minute runtime
Cold Justice (2013)
8 / 10 (based on 1807 reviews)
Reality series following former prosecutor Kelly Siegler and crime scene investigator Yolanda McClary as they crack cold cases across the U.S.
Genre: Documentary, Crime
Main Cast: Kelly Siegler, Yolanda McClary, Steve Spingola, Alan Brown
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
6 seasons, 99 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
Murder in the Heartland (2017)
7.6 / 10 (based on 361 reviews)
ID channel show featuring a true murder story in the heartland (midwest USA). Includes interviews with the victim’s family, friends, and investigators, as well as reenactments.
Genre: Crime
Main Cast: Lawrence Moran, Stuart Todd Martin, R Scott Hoffman, Fabian Jaime
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
3 seasons, 34 episodes, 42.0-minute runtime
Get Outside (2018)
No reviews
None
Genre: Documentary
Main Cast: Ben Stacey, Tim Evans, Paige Evans, Christina Scheuermann
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 6 episodes
American Monster (2016)
7.5 / 10 (based on 677 reviews)
A non-fiction crime drama uniquely telling stories with a combination of Dramatisation, home video and documentary style material.
Genre: Documentary, Crime, Drama
Main Cast: Tom Streithorst, Robert Firth, Grant Ross, Mark Behan
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
7 seasons, 71 episodes
Dead Silent (2016)
7.3 / 10 (based on 441 reviews)
A snap of a twig. A rustling leaf. In the woods, myth, urban legend, and horror collide with real-life killers. Transporting viewers into a vortex of dark mystery and psychological terror, each episode tells the true story of a crime set in a desolate location.
Genre: Documentary, Crime
Main Cast: Dude Walker, Tenzie Cameron Burns, Olivia Rachwal, Annabella Didion
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
4 seasons, 32 episodes, 42.0-minute runtime
The DNA of Murder with Paul Holes (2019)
7.3 / 10 (based on 154 reviews)
viewers will follow Holes as he dives into cold cases to analyze the violent interaction between the offender and the victim, exploring not only the physical DNA left behind but the emotional “DNA” as well.
Genre: Crime
Main Cast: Yolanda McClary, Paul Holes, Gregory Laskowski
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
1 season, 7 episodes
Murdered by Morning (2020)
6.9 / 10 (based on 97 reviews)
Friends in New Orleans hit the town looking for a night of fun. But by sunrise, one of them is found dead in the trunk of a burned out car. No one escapes suspicion, but it’s the victim’s own words that eventually help bring down her killer.
Genre: Crime
Main Cast: Lauren Berst, Nathalie Jones, Anna MacDonald, Emma Potts
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 11 episodes
Fear Thy Neighbor (2014)
7.6 / 10 (based on 871 reviews)
True crime show about conflicts between neighbors that go terribly wrong.
Genre: Action, Crime, Drama, Horror, Thriller
Main Cast: Tish Iceton, David Bacque, Craig Cyr, Drew Riedstra
Creators: James Farr
Directors:
Writers:
7 seasons, 78 episodes, 44.0-minute runtime
The Last 24 (2018)
7.9 / 10 (based on 44 reviews)
For the police the final fateful hours in the victims life becomes a puzzle. They try to understand where they were, who they met, and what happened to get their answers. The Last 24 follows investigators working the most shocking murder cases as they reconstruct those tragic final hours in the victim’s life.
Genre: Crime
Main Cast: Tommy LeNoir, Jonathan Frakes
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
2 seasons, 26 episodes, 60.0-minute runtime
A Time to Kill (2020)
7.3 / 10 (based on 96 reviews)
The key to solving the toughest homicides lies somewhere in the final hours of a victim’s life. In each one-hour episode of A Time to Kill, determined investigators must piece together events during this critical window to reconstruct the timeline, unlock the motive, and ultimately close in on the killer.
Genre: Documentary
Main Cast: Tish Iceton, Michael Arntfield, Keira Stockdale, Lori Anne Thomas
Creators:
Directors:
Writers:
4 seasons, 40 episodes
In the vast expanse of true crime television, “An Unexpected Killer” emerges as a standout series that has captivated audiences since its debut in 2019. This show takes viewers on a thrilling journey through murder cases that initially baffle investigators, only to lead them to the most unlikely culprits. The series is a masterclass in storytelling, blending suspense, mystery, and the raw emotion of real-life tragedies. Let’s explore what makes “An Unexpected Killer” a must-watch for true crime enthusiasts.
The Premise
At its core, “An Unexpected Killer” is about the unexpected twists and turns that murder investigations can take. Each episode introduces viewers to a new case, starting with the discovery of a body and the initial investigation. What sets this series apart is its focus on cases where the killer is someone no one would have suspected at first glance. These are not stories of random acts of violence by strangers but rather tales of betrayal, jealousy, and hidden secrets within families, friendships, and communities.
The Format
The show follows a tried-and-true format that works exceptionally well for the genre. Episodes typically begin with the discovery of the victim, followed by interviews with family members, friends, and law enforcement officers involved in the case. As the investigation unfolds, viewers are presented with various suspects, each with plausible motives and opportunities. However, the true strength of the show lies in its ability to keep the audience guessing until the very end, when the unexpected killer is finally revealed.
Unforgettable Cases
Over the course of its run, “An Unexpected Killer” has presented a wide array of cases, each with its own unique set of circumstances and emotional depth. Some of the most memorable episodes involve cases where the killer is someone incredibly close to the victim, such as a spouse, sibling, or best friend. These stories challenge our perceptions of trust and loyalty, leaving us to wonder how well we truly know those closest to us.
For instance, one episode delves into the murder of a young woman found dead in her own home. Initially, the investigation focuses on potential break-ins and known criminals in the area. However, as detectives dig deeper, they uncover a web of lies and deceit within the victim’s inner circle, ultimately leading to a shocking conclusion that no one saw coming.
The Appeal
What makes “An Unexpected Killer” so appealing to viewers? There are several factors at play. First and foremost, the show taps into our innate fascination with the darker aspects of human nature. It explores the reasons why someone might commit the ultimate betrayal against those they supposedly care about. Additionally, the series is meticulously researched and well-produced, with reenactments and interviews that draw viewers into the story without resorting to sensationalism.
Moreover, the show serves as a reminder of the complexity of murder investigations. It highlights the dedication and perseverance of law enforcement officers as they work tirelessly to uncover the truth, often in the face of dead ends and false leads. It’s a testament to the fact that solving a murder is rarely straightforward and that the path to justice can be long and winding.
Impact on Viewers
“An Unexpected Killer” does more than just entertain; it also educates and informs. By showcasing the intricacies of criminal investigations, the show provides valuable insights into the forensic and psychological tools used to solve crimes. It encourages viewers to think critically about evidence, motives, and alibis, engaging them in a mental puzzle that’s both intriguing and enlightening.
Additionally, the series has a profound emotional impact. It humanizes the victims, giving voice to their stories and highlighting the devastating effects of their loss on families and communities. This emotional connection adds another layer of depth to the show, making it not just a series of crime stories, but a poignant exploration of grief, loss, and the search for justice.
Conclusion
“An Unexpected Killer” stands out in the crowded field of true crime television by offering a unique perspective on murder investigations. It challenges our assumptions, keeps us on the edge of our seats, and touches our hearts. Whether you’re a seasoned true crime aficionado or new to the genre, this series offers something for everyone. It’s a reminder of the complexities of human relationships, the unpredictability of life, and the relentless pursuit of truth in the face of adversity. In a world where the truth is often stranger than fiction, “An Unexpected Killer” proves that the most shocking stories are those that happen in real life.